Home » Pro-Democracy Forces in Serbia Targeted with Spyware
General News Human Rights News

Pro-Democracy Forces in Serbia Targeted with Spyware



Digital and human rights watchdogs have documented the first case of spyware abuse in Serbia targeting civil society representatives.


That government critics are spied on in Serbia is nothing new. What is new, however, is that Citizen LabAccess Now and Amnesty International in cooperation with the Belgrade-based SHARE Foundation have found evidence that two members of Serbian civil society – both openly critical of the government – were targeted with spyware.

The independent investigations came after Apple notified iPhone users worldwide that they may have been targeted by ‘state-sponsored attackers’. The attackers attempted to exploit the iPhone’s HomeKit functionality, a tactic consistent with those previously used by NSO Group’s Pegasus spyware. Still, investigators have not, for now, attributed the attacks to one particular operator.

Collecting more evidence about infected mobile devices would help determine both the vendor and the attacker. Nevertheless, previous research has shown that Serbian security services have been clients of cyber-espionage firms for almost a decade. Serbia’s main intelligence agency has a track record of deploying spyware and other digital surveillance tools, such as Cytrox’s PredatorCirclesCyberbit, and FinSpy.

Even government bodies not mandated to provide security, such as the former Ministry of Trade, Tourism and Telecommunication, have shown interest in purchasing Cognyte spyware that gives authorities the power to listen in on calls, view text messages and web traffic including emails, and track the location of users without the assistance of telecom and internet firms.

Most of the sophisticated spyware was purchased from Israeli companies that are leaders in this field.

Israeli companies often insist that their products are sold directly to governments for use against criminals and terrorists. But reports from big tech companies, such as Meta, have concluded that the targets are journalists, dissidents, critics of authoritarian regimes, families of opposition members and human rights activists around the world.

In the case of Serbia, intrusive surveillance technologies have been procured in murky circumstances, without proper due diligence or any transparency.

Absence of democratic civilian control


Photo: Pixabay/Macedo_Media

The Serbian government often relies on public and private companies as intermediaries to purchase spyware from vendors. For example, in 2017 then Defence Minister Aleksandar Vulin visited Elbit Systems’ Israeli subsidiary, Cyberbit Ltd. and the company’s software was later detected in a business complex in Belgrade belonging to Delta Holding, owned by Miroslav Miskovic, a well-known Serbian tycoon and sponsor of the former and current political elite.

The weakest link is the absence of democratic civilian control of the executive, which is why Serbia’s top security officials continue to [mis]use advanced technology with few, if any, guardrails.

An illustrative example of this came when police under Vulin in his later role as interior minister recorded meetings of Russian opposition politicians in Belgrade in 2021 and handed the transcripts to Nikolai Patrushev, Secretary of the Russian Security Council.

Though Vulin has publicly denied passing information to Patrushev, his visit to Moscow preceded the arrest and imprisonment of activist and Open Russia director Andrei Pivovarov and Russian-British activist and journalist Vladimir Kara-Murza, who both attended the meetings in Belgrade. Ultimately, this has had a chilling effect on freedom of expression, freedom of assembly, and the right to privacy in Serbia.

Even more concerning is the fact that Vulin, who also served until recently as Serbia’s intelligence chief, was sanctioned earlier this year by the US in part for enabling “Russia’s malign activities in the region” and his alleged involvement in illegal arms shipments, drug trafficking, and misuse of public office.

With this in mind, most civil society representatives believe that the use of spyware in a country with poor governance and loose ‘checks and balances’ constitutes a threat to democracy and human rights.

Moreover, there is a widespread fear that advanced surveillance technology would allow Serbian authorities to exercise more robust political control over critics of the regime. It is no coincidence that the proliferation of spyware in Serbia coincides with mass protests against political violence and growing public discontent with the autocratic rule of President Aleksandar Vucic.

In this context, the use of spyware, including the installation of Chinese smart surveillance cameras – which are mushrooming across Serbia – is being legitimised in propagandised rhetoric, especially in the aftermath of protests.

Government officials are using belligerent rhetoric to convey the message that intrusive surveillance tools are legitimate to combat ‘colour revolution’ and ‘foreign mercenaries’ who, the officials claim, want to overthrow the Serbian leadership with the help of outside intelligence agencies.

Serbian government’s cyber toolkit


Photo: Pixabay/mvezokaramchandhay

The unchecked use of commercial spyware against critics of the Serbian regime is just the tip of the iceberg. The cyber toolkit of the ruling Serbian Progressive Party includes thousands of trolls, mostly paid from public funds, who regularly attack political dissenters on social media.

In the context of December’s snap elections, the latest state-sponsored cyber-attack involves an attempt to blackmail a member of the opposition bloc ‘Serbia Against Violence’ with intimate pictures and footage from a stolen laptop. This attack was announced by Vucic on TV Pink – a channel that later published an intimate video that resulted in the withdrawal of the opponent from the election race.

More than once, the security services eavesdropped on the conversations of investigative journalists and their sources and later used it for a slanderous campaign in Serbian tabloids. In addition, personal data from police records was repeatedly published in government-affiliated tabloids, targeting political dissenters. One very well-known case in this context concerned the leaking of biometric data of the state attorney in charge of high-profile organised crime cases involving state officials.

During the pandemic, Serbian civil society and the media came under enormous pressure due to their work on exposing organised crime, corruption and human rights abuses. Then the finance ministry officially requested data and financial transactions from all commercial banks in Serbia for 57 non-profits, media and individuals suspected of “money laundering and terrorist financing”.

The list is not exhaustive, but it shows that with the help of digital surveillance tools, the government is trying to control every aspect of people’s lives, intimidate and discredit critical voices, expose journalists’ sources and put pressure on independent state institutions.

It is therefore crucial to secure a nation-wide debate on the risks associated with intrusive technology, transparent regulation of such systems to ensure the protection of fundamental human rights, as well as rigorous independent oversight of state and non-state actors using surveillance systems.

Maja Bjelos is a senior researcher at the Belgrade Centre for Security Policy

The opinions expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of BIRN.

Source : Balkan Insight

Instagram

Instagram has returned empty data. Please authorize your Instagram account in the plugin settings .

Advertisement

Advertisement Small

Flickr

  • Capiton
  • Neons
  • Sugar version
  • Corbeille
  • Katia
  • Les anémones
  • Rêverie
  • L'usurier
  • Ha Phurong (actress, "Cu Li never cries" - Pham Ngoc Lan) Vietnam - Berlinale 74°

ThemeForest

Collaboratively harness market-driven processes whereas resource-leveling internal or "organic" sources. Competently formulate.

Calendar

March 2024
M T W T F S S
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

RSS Meks Blog

  • 10 Best Knowledge Base & Wiki WordPress Themes 2021 September 15, 2021
    Running a successful online business requires an exceptional WordPress knowledge base theme that organizes documentation and helps customers. Customization options, intuitive navigation, unique layouts, and fast responsiveness are just some of the features you need. The following 10 WordPress wiki themes represent the best options for 2021 and beyond. Explore the full range to determine […]
    Dusan Milovanovic
  • How to increase WordPress Memory Limit (quick fixes) June 16, 2021
    Here is a post about how to increase the memory limit in WordPress. Allowed memory size exhausted error message showed up in your WordPress installation? No worries – this is one of the most common errors in WordPress. You can apply an easy fix by increasing the memory limit in your PHP. Table of Contents […]
    Dusan Milovanovic
  • How to use (and why) WordPress sitemap plugin March 1, 2021
    Did you know that by knowing how to use the WordPress sitemap plugin you can significantly improve your site’s visibility and traffic? Although it isn’t mandatory to have a sitemap on your site, having one significantly improves the site’s quality, crawlability and indexing. All this is important for better optimization, which is why we wanted […]
    Ivana Cirkovic
  • 22 free and premium podcast software for your show [2021 edition] January 18, 2021
    You’re determined to start or improve your podcast but don’t know which podcast software to use to really make it stand out? We’ve got you! #podcasting Top 22 free and premium podcast software for your show #WordPressTips #podcasting The post 22 free and premium podcast software for your show [2021 edition] appeared first on Meks.
    Ivana Cirkovic
  • Digital storytelling with WordPress – an all-in-one guide to make your web stories pop! November 23, 2020
    Wondering how to improve digital storytelling with WordPress and build more awareness and exposure of your business? Let our guide lead the way. The post Digital storytelling with WordPress – an all-in-one guide to make your web stories pop! appeared first on Meks.
    Ivana Cirkovic
  • How to use WordPress autoposting plugin to improve your visibility and SEO? September 10, 2020
    Did you know you can use the WordPress autoposting plugin for your content efforts and improve not only your time management but your business and visibility as well? The post How to use WordPress autoposting plugin to improve your visibility and SEO? appeared first on Meks.
    Ivana Cirkovic
  • How to create a personal branding site? Step-by-step DIY guide August 15, 2020
    Looking for ways and means to create a personal branding site? Well, look no further ’cause we’re giving away all the how-to’s to do it yourselves! The post How to create a personal branding site? Step-by-step DIY guide appeared first on Meks.
    Ivana Cirkovic
  • Top 15 WordPress content plugins and tools to improve your visibility and rankings July 16, 2020
    Let’s take a look at some of the must-have WordPress content plugins and tools to use to improve both your UX and rankings. The post Top 15 WordPress content plugins and tools to improve your visibility and rankings appeared first on Meks.
    Ivana Cirkovic
  • WCEU 2020 recap – key takeaways from the biggest online WordPress conference June 9, 2020
    Missed WCEU 2020 and all the exciting stuff from there? Here are all the key takeaways and main points to remember so, take notes! The post WCEU 2020 recap – key takeaways from the biggest online WordPress conference appeared first on Meks.
    Ivana Cirkovic
  • How to change the WordPress username? An easy step-by-step guide May 14, 2020
    Wondering how can you change WordPress username once you set up your blog or site? Read all about it in our helpful guide! The post How to change the WordPress username? An easy step-by-step guide appeared first on Meks.
    Ivana Cirkovic

Text

Distinctively utilize long-term high-impact total linkage whereas high-payoff experiences. Appropriately communicate 24/365.